I have to say this.
Firstly, thank you, Xana, for hosting the RP and creating this universe for us to move in. It has been an interesting time.
Secondly, Sicon, please. It has been eight months since your last post on the RoH game thread. You of all players have the least right to put on a cloak of self-righteousness and be angry that the RP is being shut down. It's on you. I will not stand to see anger being directed towards the GM who gave us this platform where it is undeserved.
To the best of my comprehension, the issue here is that what was intended to be a simple one-off sidequest has gone on to have a deeper plot of its own, which is not something that sidequests ought to be having unless specifically directed to be so. Turning the one small sidequest into something larger that spans multiple posts, in my opinion, was what Xana did not approve of. (Correct me if I am wrong here, Xana.)
Looking to my own sidequest with Endless, while it may have spanned several posts, my justification here is that it was two people not doing a single collaborative post but doing a back-and-forth. Even then, Endless and I likely should have found a time to put it together in one post, but we did not have the luxury of syncing up timezones. Comparatively, Mimsy's sidestory, despite being solo, has a greater post count than what Endless and I have done together, and is still not yet finished.
The depth involved in the sidequest can be disruptive, from the GM's point of view. Say, hypothetically, that Xana has a structure for the city in mind in terms of social hierarchy. Maybe he planned for the presence of mages to be minimal, but suddenly there are magic antagonists such as Nihilus, who are the results of magical experimentation. The city then becomes disrupted, from the GM's point of view, and this is invisible to us players because we rightly don't know his plans. The 'power level' of the city/region, for want of a better phrase, becomes messed up. While I account is as fair that we as players can add in our own factions and the like, we ought to check first with the GM whether such an organisation makes sense within his universe. Adding your own thing, then complaining when the GM objects is bad form. The onus is on you to provide the GM with enough information about your plot line, your ability to post in a timely fashion, so that he can plan around and take into account your plans and/or determine whether those plans are plausible in the setting.
Time is the other factor. As a GM, can you imagine how frustrated Xana must be, with all his plans and plots being put on hold simply because of what was originally intended to be a miniature diversion from the main plot to add a little variety into the story?
Lordxana0 on Jan 14 wrote:Everyone ready to advance the story? If not please finish up your missions so we can advance. Once everyone is finished please all take a post so you know where your character is resting for the night, the next day something big will happen for all new fun.
Xana had already given a lot of time allowance for the completion of quests. That was four months ago. Do not complain that he is being unfair, because he has been kind in the extreme. You say that you enjoy writing Procyon, Sicon, but when there's been no post for over half a year, that rings rather hollow.
Let me appeal to you as players, Sicon and Mimsy. I know you both enjoy writing long, complex and intricate plots. However, a role-playing game, particularly one on a forum, is more than just a personal game. Yes, you write because you enjoy it. But RPs involve other people as well; every player bears a responsibility to each other player to post within a reasonable timeframe, to leave space for the involvement of other characters where appropriate, to adhere to the GM's rules because in the end it is not so much our game but his. If you have an issue with a GM's ruling, and that issue is justified, then by all means bring it up. But spare the GM the vitriol he does not deserve. If you know that you are unable to get the post up within a reasonable amount of time due to real-life matters, inform the GM. If the timeframe you need is too long, then the GM reserves every right to skip your turn. Decision lies with the GM. At every single point of the game, the GM reserves the right to end the game.
Post what is appropriate. Breaking character limit doesn't make your post better. Having excessive length does not justify taking excessive time, because long posts have the tendency to turn people off from reading, and because other players are forced to wait for you. Causing the game to freeze, then raging when no more extra time is allowed? That's bad manners, and exceptionally wrong. You're playing among friends, so treat them with the respect they deserve.
All I'm asking is for you to respect roleplay etiquette. These are codes of conduct that you agree to by playing the GM's game. Xana does not deserve your anger. Nobody does. I admire the way both of you can craft together lengthy posts, and interesting descriptions as well as well-thought-out fight scenes. But what is happening here is unacceptable because you are faulting Xana for doing something that is not only well within his rights, but entirely appropriate to the situation. Accept it with good grace. Stubbornly continuing the RP after it has been declared closed is insulting to the GM, particularly when you didn't continue it while it was alive.
These points apply to all of us, and it is not my intention for either Sicon or Mimsy to feel victimised. These are things that we must abide by, or else risk miscommunication or worse. Thank you for taking the time to read this post, and thank you once more, Xana.