Watch the Footage

Noooooo, not the two nice people~!

Qara was indeed the Blue Demoman.

Eli, meanwhile, was the Blue Medic.

The Blue team has self-destructed. The Red Team wins.

Meanwhile, Endless sneaks away to report back to his diabolical master... He was the Gray Spy.

Anura wrote:Eli, meanwhile, was the Blue Medic.
Meanwhile, Eli sneaks away to report back to his diabolical master... He was the Gray Spy.

What?

Anura wrote:Qara was indeed the Blue Demoman.

Eli, meanwhile, was the Blue Medic.

The Blue team has self-destructed. The Red Team wins.

Meanwhile, Eli sneaks away to report back to his diabolical master... He was the Gray Spy.

Something seems fishy....also, I'm saddened by how fast that went.

...wasn't I the Gray Spy?

Anura wrote:Once again, you are Gray Mann's robot. This time however, you are the Gray Spy. You win the game if you're still alive at the end, regardless of Red or Blue victory (the winning team also wins; you don't steal their victory)

^ From my inbox, that was.

So let me get this straight.

Jack died of poison. The only character who can poison is the Blue Medic, which is who Eli probably was, given that we only seemed to have three Blues and Endless is saying they're the Gray Spy.

Jack was a Blue Heavy. This means that, for whatever reason, Eli deliberately set out to kill one of her own team.

Qara then self-destructed and took Eli with her. They were also both Blue, and resulted in Blue's complete self-destruction. Whether this was a continuation of a plan to kill Blue or a reaction to Eli possibly being traitorous, I can't say. Given Qara's reaction, though ("Okay so IN LIGHT OF THIS NEWS..."), it sounds like this isn't an outcome Qara was expecting.

...I have a feeling something went terribly wrong.

Oh sorry Soph. I was expecting everything perfectly fine. I just prefaced my murder-suicide like that in order to make things more dramatic/confusing.

We still need to figure out how the other two people died, but since it's almost midnight, I am going to sleep, and am probably NOT going to die in the middle of the night.

Did we have a stealth night phase before we started? Because eli didn't do anything last night (according to my Red Spy-iness), and poison takes a day to kick in...

Not playing, but from what I glean; Qara and Eli were the only two Blue left, and Qara instantly blew both of them up. Endless was the Grey Spy and won along with the Red team.

The stuff that doesn't seem to make sense, I'd attribute to Anura being tipsy after taking all those gender confusion cups due to the drinking game rules - Which, by the way, means you still have another one to tip over Anura. You called eli a he, again.

So, we had a Blue Medic, a Blue Demoman and a Blue Heavy. They killed themselves while I assume either Qara or Jack killed Narra/Sophira. On the next day, Qara blew Eli and herself up. Which means... The real person we're against this game was either Endless or whomever killed the extra person during Night 1? Or did each person of the Blue team kill someone on the first night? Or something else I'm missing?

Nah, the Blue Team just up and decided to ruin the game.

Eli poisoned Jack during Day 1, so it kicked in during the night. Here's my notes on the night...

• Narra spychecked Victin and ran into Victin's turret.
• Tohr spied on Eli and saw nothing
• Jack sandviched Endless before succumbing to poison despite Sophira protecting him from Krika's shot.
• Krika shot Jack, Sophira dove in front of the bullet. But Jack was already dead from the poison. Qara finished Soph off as BLU's official nightkill.
• Victin tried to give Soph the scanner, but she died. He did give Krika the dispenser, though, and killed Narra as previously mentioned.
• Dryu didn't drink his BONK!.

Hah! Shows what you know, Jack. I'm a robot, so I don't care about sandviches! :P

More on topic, wow, that's convoluted. Go figure.

Wait, so I didn't actually successfully shoot anyone?

This was ridiculously convoluted. I like it.

Well technically you shot Jack, who was already dead, and/or Soph, who was already marked for death. Great job!

Qara-Xuan Zenith wrote:Well technically you shot Jack, who was already dead, and/or Soph, who was already marked for death. Great job!

Good news guys, I have made a spy detector out of my--


Why is the base on fire? And why are you all so happy about it?

(( Okay, seriously now - this is what I come to? Qara has some explaining to do. ))

Dryunya wrote:(( Okay, seriously now - this is what I come to? Qara has some explaining to do. ))

Eli and Jack and I were the Blue Team (=mafia). We (well, mostly eli and jack) thought it would be funny if we self-destructed. So eli poisoned jack and then I murder-suicided myself and eli. We also murdered Soph to throw off suspicion.

I can't answer for what everybody else was doing.

Qara-Xuan Zenith wrote:We thought it would be funny if we self-destructed

I have a lot of contradicting reactions to this. That was weird, but kinda funny; that was unexpected, but we should have seen something weird coming. This is why we can't have nice things, but this is why it's awesome being a Metaguard, you guys.

Dryunya wrote:

Qara-Xuan Zenith wrote:We thought it would be funny if we self-destructed

I have a lot of contradicting reactions to this. That was weird, but kinda funny; that was unexpected, but we should have seen something weird coming. This is why we can't have nice things, but this is why it's awesome being a Metaguard, you guys.

I think it'd be funnier if there were more Mafia. With three it was kinda... Fast.

More than a third of the players in the mafia aproches dangerously unbalanced levels.

I feel like giving this variant another go, but I don't know if we can get the necessary nine players. Sound off if interested!

Oh man, I have not been on the forum in a very long time, but I would love to give this another go. Not that it looks like we have the numbers for it. =P

Didn't we discuss this in slackchat? I think we had a few people who were interested.

I wouldn't know if it'd been discussed on Slack. It seems like a cool idea, at any rate.